Life · Infinity Games

200+ paywall tests, and the one that won

The old paywall showed up before the value did. I treated every paywall like an experiment, and ran over 200 of them.

DraftPublished Updated 2 min read

This is a working draft. I’m still filling it in.

  • +23%

    Revenue from one paywall

  • +40%

    Paid growth on iOS

  • 20×

    In-app purchases

  • 37%

    Of monthly users on paid plans

On this page
  1. How I tested: watch, test, tweak
  2. 200+ versions, each one a small bet
  3. The winner: Easter Surprise
  4. What I learned
  5. Keep reading

How I tested: watch, test, tweak

I treated every important flow like something I could test, watch and tweak, one experiment at a time.

Every flow ran on the same loop: guess, test, learn, change. We ran it on acquisition, onboarding, engagement and the paywall.

  1. Watch what people do

    Mixpanel funnels showed where women dropped off, flow by flow.

  2. Test one change

    Every drop-off became one focused A/B test, from onboarding steps to paywall copy.

  3. Nail the first impression

    App Store tests tried out screenshots and messages before anyone even installed.

  4. Listen

    200+ interviews and threads about stress, mood and cycles showed us where our words didn't land.

This loop kept us honest. A change only shipped if it moved a number, and the interviews told me why it moved. I built the winning ideas into patterns we could reuse and A/B test again.

200+ versions, each one a small bet

The paywalls that won were rarely the prettiest. They said the value out loud, right when a woman was already feeling it.

I tested headlines, prices, plan options, buttons, illustrations, even punctuation. Each version was a small bet I could measure.

I planned a paywall for each step of the journey and priced each one to the moment. Onboarding offered a free trial. If she closed it, she saw a lower price. The home screen ran a banner, generic or seasonal. Locked premium features had their own paywall. When she came back to the app, the price matched that visit.

Life onboarding paywall offering a personalized plan

Onboarding

Life in-app upgrade screen listing premium benefits

Upgrade

Two of the versions: the onboarding paywall, which converted the most, and the in-app upgrade.

The winner: Easter Surprise

One paywall beat every other version on revenue: Easter Surprise bumped it 23%.

Four things made it work:

  • A simple, direct message.
  • It went live over Easter weekend.
  • An image that felt real.
  • A short offer with a deadline.

It offered half price for good, but only for a few days. If you tried to close it, a sad bunny asked: “Are you sure you don’t want a discount?”

Easter Surprise paywall with a time-limited discount on Life Premium
Easter Surprise: +23% revenue.

Together with the onboarding and pricing tests, the paywall work brought +40% paid growth on iOS and 20× in-app purchases. 37% of monthly users were on paid plans.

What I learned

  • Better-looking designs didn’t always win. In several tests, the less polished one beat the clean one. Paywalls win on clarity and timing.
  • Small bets you can measure add up. 200 tests taught me more than any big redesign.

Topics: experimentation, growth, data. Also as plain markdown.